More homeowner feedback than nearby roofers
This profile has more Google reviews than 33 of 62 nearby roofing contractors.
Compared with 62 other nearby roofers
Weather Tight Roofing
Roofing contractor · Madison, WI
Homeowner snapshot
What stands out about Weather Tight Roofing
A 4.9 rating is easier to judge when you know what is behind it. This profile combines review history, nearby comparisons, and recent public updates from the business.
The Google review count is unchanged since Jun 11, 2026
The rating stayed at 4.9.
47 Jun 11, 2026
47 Jul 29, 2026
What the business has posted about lately
Recent public business posts repeatedly mention shingle roofing, roof replacement, and gutter work. This shows what the business has been promoting recently, not every service or area it may cover.
Based on 5 business posts through Jul 17, 2026
Shingle roofing 
Shingle roofing 
Shingle roofing See the recent-post breakdown
Shingle roofing4 of 5 recent business posts mention shingle roofing.
Roof replacement2 of 5 recent business posts mention roof replacement.
Gutter work1 of 5 recent business posts mention gutter work.
Roof repair1 of 5 recent business posts mention roof repair.
Storm-related roofing work1 of 5 recent business posts mention storm-related roofing work.
Post counts can include several updates about similar work. They do not prove that each post represents a separate completed project.
The customer experience
What customers tend to mention
Google groups recurring phrases from the reviews. Open any stage to see the exact themes behind our plain-English summary.
01 Roofing work mentionedGoogle's review themes include siding replacement, gutter work, plywood replacement, window replacement, facia replacement, and door replacement.
siding replacementgutter workplywood replacementwindow replacementfacia replacementdoor replacement
02 Crew and follow-throughGoogle's review themes include thorough crew.
thorough crew
03 Other customer themesGoogle's review themes also include polite team, competitive pricing, and diligent workers.
polite teamcompetitive pricingdiligent workers
Before you hire
Questions to ask Weather Tight Roofing
These questions come from the public review themes shown above. They are prompts, not warnings or conclusions about this company.
Which roofing system fits this project?
Ask which materials and installation method are recommended for your roof and why.
Who will be on site and supervise the work?
Confirm who leads the crew, the expected work hours, and who handles concerns during the job.
Profile source: Public business listing. Own this business? Get free access to edit your listing. Updates are reviewed before publication. Google Maps data checked July 2026.